DeepRead

Most argued over books on Hacker News

This ranking picks out the 150 books, from 15,732 in the library, that draw the most disagreement. It measures recommenders and critics both, so a title ranks high when many commenters praise it and many others pan it. That makes it a good guide to contested reading. Fifty Shades of Grey, The Population Bomb and IQ and the wealth of nations lead the list. Bestselling thrillers, controversial science and race debates also appear, including The Da Vinci Code and The Bell Curve.

Recommenders and critics both: the top 150 of 15,732 books mentioned in Hacker News comments.

By region

The list

  1. 1
    Fifty Shades of Grey
    E. L. James · 2011 · recommended by 1 person · 18 of 19 people were critical
  2. 2
    The Population Bomb
    Paul R. Ehrlich · 1968 · recommended by 1 person · 12 of 13 people were critical
  3. 3
    IQ and the wealth of nations
    Richard Lynn · 2002 · recommended by 2 people · 14 of 16 people were critical
  4. 4
    The Da Vinci Code
    Dan Brown · 2003 · recommended by 6 people · 40 of 46 people were critical
  5. 5
    Mein Kampf
    Adolf Hitler · 1925 · recommended by 15 people · 54 of 69 people were critical
  6. 6
    In search of excellence
    Thomas J. Peters · 1982 · recommended by 3 people · 10 of 13 people were critical
  7. 7
    Chariots of the gods?
    Erich von Däniken · 1968 · recommended by 3 people · 10 of 13 people were critical
  8. 8
    A new kind of science
    Stephen Wolfram · 2002 · recommended by 44 people · 120 of 164 people were critical
  9. 9
    White Fragility
    Robin J. DiAngelo · 2018 · recommended by 10 people · 23 of 33 people were critical
  10. 10
    The bell curve
    Richard J. Herrnstein · 1994 · recommended by 6 people · 13 of 19 people were critical
  11. 11
    Digital Fortress
    Dan Brown · 1998 · recommended by 10 people · 14 of 24 people were critical
  12. 12
    Finnegan's wake
    James Joyce · 1939 · recommended by 16 people · 17 of 33 people were critical
  13. 13
    Atlas Shrugged
    Ayn Rand · 1957 · recommended by 207 people · 208 of 415 people were critical
  14. 14
    Lord of the Flies
    William Golding · 1954 · recommended by 32 people · 32 of 64 people were critical
  15. 15
    State of Fear
    Michael Crichton · 2004 · recommended by 11 people · 11 of 22 people were critical
  16. 16
    Rich Dad, Poor Dad
    Robert T. Kiyosaki · 1990 · recommended by 96 people · 89 of 185 people were critical
  17. 17
    The age of spiritual machines
    Ray Kurzweil · 1999 · recommended by 13 people · 11 of 24 people were critical
  18. 18
    The Mismeasure of Man
    Stephen Jay Gould · 1981 · recommended by 22 people · 17 of 39 people were critical
  19. 19
    Silicon snake oil
    Clifford Stoll · 1995 · recommended by 13 people · 10 of 23 people were critical
  20. 20
    Clean Code
    Robert C. Martin · 2008 · recommended by 298 people · 212 of 510 people were critical
  21. 21
    Compilers, principles, techniques, and tools
    Alfred V. Aho · 1986 · recommended by 195 people · 137 of 332 people were critical
  22. 22
    Blink
    Malcolm Gladwell · 2005 · recommended by 29 people · 20 of 49 people were critical
  23. 23
    The Catcher in the Rye
    J. D. Salinger · 1951 · recommended by 60 people · 41 of 101 people were critical
  24. 24
    Design Patterns
    Erich Gamma · 1994 · recommended by 95 people · 63 of 158 people were critical
  25. 25
    Flash Boys
    Michael Lewis · 2014 · recommended by 76 people · 50 of 126 people were critical
  26. 26
    The China Study
    T. Colin Campbell, PhD · 2005 · recommended by 30 people · 19 of 49 people were critical
  27. 27
    The Wheel of Time
    Robert Jordan · 1990 · recommended by 57 people · 36 of 93 people were critical
  28. 28
    Consider Phlebas
    Iain Banks · 1987 · recommended by 69 people · 42 of 111 people were critical
  29. 29
    The Great Gatsby
    F. Scott Fitzgerald · 1925 · recommended by 58 people · 34 of 92 people were critical
  30. 30
    Limits to Growth
    Donella H. Meadows · 1972 · recommended by 19 people · 10 of 29 people were critical
  31. 31
    The Singularity Is Near
    Ray Kurzweil · 2005 · recommended by 30 people · 15 of 45 people were critical
  32. 32
    The Silmarillion
    J.R.R. Tolkien · 1977 · recommended by 28 people · 14 of 42 people were critical
  33. 33
    Reamde
    Neal Stephenson · 2011 · recommended by 56 people · 27 of 83 people were critical
  34. 34
    Ulysses
    James Joyce · 1922 · recommended by 46 people · 21 of 67 people were critical
  35. 35
    Das Kapital
    Karl Marx · 1867 · recommended by 40 people · 18 of 58 people were critical
  36. 36
    The God Delusion
    Richard Dawkins · 2006 · recommended by 41 people · 18 of 59 people were critical
  37. 37
    The Origin of Species
    Charles Darwin · 2002 · recommended by 30 people · 13 of 43 people were critical
  38. 38
    Emperor's New Mind
    Roger Penrose · 1989 · recommended by 37 people · 15 of 52 people were critical
  39. 39
    Communist Manifesto
    Karl Marx · 1848 · recommended by 31 people · 12 of 43 people were critical
  40. 40
    Good to Great
    Collins, James C. · 2001 · recommended by 71 people · 27 of 98 people were critical
  41. 41
    Moby Dick
    Herman Melville · 1851 · recommended by 119 people · 45 of 164 people were critical
  42. 42
    Ready Player One
    Ernest Cline · 2011 · recommended by 123 people · 46 of 169 people were critical
  43. 43
    The Shock Doctrine
    Naomi Klein · 2007 · recommended by 27 people · 10 of 37 people were critical
  44. 44
    The Dark Tower
    Stephen King · 2004 · recommended by 27 people · 10 of 37 people were critical
  45. 45
    Three felonies a day
    Harvey A. Silverglate · 2009 · recommended by 33 people · 12 of 45 people were critical
  46. 46
    The 48 Laws of Power
    Robert Greene · 1998 · recommended by 85 people · 30 of 115 people were critical
  47. 47
    Gravity's Rainbow
    Thomas Pynchon · 1973 · recommended by 58 people · 20 of 78 people were critical
  48. 48
    Clean Architecture
    Robert C. Martin · 2017 · recommended by 47 people · 16 of 63 people were critical
  49. 49
    Seveneves
    Neal Stephenson · 2015 · recommended by 188 people · 63 of 251 people were critical
  50. 50
    Foundation
    Isaac Asimov · 1951 · recommended by 143 people · 47 of 190 people were critical
  51. 51
    Guns, Germs, and Steel
    Jared Diamond · 1997 · recommended by 214 people · 70 of 284 people were critical
  52. 52
    Termination Shock
    Neal Stephenson · 2021 · recommended by 34 people · 11 of 45 people were critical
  53. 53
    Stranger in a Strange Land
    Robert A. Heinlein · 1961 · recommended by 97 people · 31 of 128 people were critical
  54. 54
    Cracking The Coding Interview
    Gayle Laakmann McDowell · 2010 · recommended by 178 people · 54 of 232 people were critical
  55. 55
    Why We Sleep
    Matthew P. Walker · 2017 · recommended by 202 people · 60 of 262 people were critical
  56. 56
    Homo Deus
    Yuval Noah Harari · 2015 · recommended by 44 people · 13 of 57 people were critical
  57. 57
    The Ministry for the Future
    Kim Stanley Robinson · 2020 · recommended by 69 people · 20 of 89 people were critical
  58. 58
    Outliers
    Malcolm Gladwell · 2008 · recommended by 99 people · 28 of 127 people were critical
  59. 59
    The Fountainhead
    Ayn Rand · 1943 · recommended by 64 people · 18 of 82 people were critical
  60. 60
    Harry Potter
    J. K. Rowling · 2001 · recommended by 55 people · 15 of 70 people were critical
  61. 61
    The Elements of Style
    William Strunk, Jr. · 1918 · recommended by 131 people · 35 of 166 people were critical
  62. 62
    Steve Jobs
    Walter Isaacson · 2011 · recommended by 64 people · 17 of 81 people were critical
  63. 63
    Old Man’s War
    John Scalzi · 2005 · recommended by 42 people · 11 of 53 people were critical
  64. 64
    Learn C the hard way
    Zed Shaw · 2015 · recommended by 70 people · 18 of 88 people were critical
  65. 65
    The Black Swan
    Nassim Nicholas Taleb · 2007 · recommended by 263 people · 67 of 330 people were critical
  66. 66
    Bullshit Jobs
    David Graeber · 2018 · recommended by 153 people · 38 of 191 people were critical
  67. 67
    Introduction to Algorithms
    Thomas H. Cormen · 1990 · recommended by 274 people · 67 of 341 people were critical
  68. 68
    The art of computer programming
    Donald Knuth · 1968 · recommended by 336 people · 82 of 418 people were critical
  69. 69
    Baroque Cycle
    Neal Stephenson · 2003 · recommended by 115 people · 28 of 143 people were critical
  70. 70
    Applied Cryptography
    Bruce Schneier · 1994 · recommended by 76 people · 18 of 94 people were critical
  71. 71
    Ender's Game
    Orson Scott Card · 1985 · recommended by 169 people · 40 of 209 people were critical
  72. 72
    Three-Body Problem
    Cixin Liu · 2006 · recommended by 233 people · 55 of 288 people were critical
  73. 73
    Infinite Jest
    David Foster Wallace · 1996 · recommended by 145 people · 34 of 179 people were critical
  74. 74
    Effective Modern C++
    Scott Meyers · 2014 · recommended by 63 people · 14 of 77 people were critical
  75. 75
    A History of Western Philosophy
    Bertrand Russell · 1945 · recommended by 64 people · 14 of 78 people were critical
  76. 76
    Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality
    Eliezer Yudkowsky · 2010 · recommended by 170 people · 37 of 207 people were critical
  77. 77
    The Coddling of the American Mind
    Greg Lukianoff · 2018 · recommended by 51 people · 11 of 62 people were critical
  78. 78
    Snow Crash
    Neal Stephenson · 1992 · recommended by 364 people · 77 of 441 people were critical
  79. 79
    The better angels of our nature
    Steven Pinker · 2011 · recommended by 72 people · 15 of 87 people were critical
  80. 80
    The Cathedral and the Bazaar
    Eric S. Raymond · 1999 · recommended by 72 people · 15 of 87 people were critical
  81. 81
    War and Peace
    Lev Tolstoi · 1845 · recommended by 78 people · 16 of 94 people were critical
  82. 82
    The Glass Bead Game
    Hermann Hesse · 1943 · recommended by 51 people · 10 of 61 people were critical
  83. 83
    Ringworld
    Larry Niven · 1970 · recommended by 51 people · 10 of 61 people were critical
  84. 84
    Neuromancer
    William Gibson · 1984 · recommended by 296 people · 58 of 354 people were critical
  85. 85
    Crime and punishment
    1984 · recommended by 113 people · 22 of 135 people were critical
  86. 86
    Starship Troopers
    Robert A. Heinlein · 1959 · recommended by 57 people · 11 of 68 people were critical
  87. 87
    Learn You a Haskell for Great Good!
    Miran Lipovača · 2011 · recommended by 237 people · 45 of 282 people were critical
  88. 88
    Real World Haskell
    Bryan O'Sullivan · 2008 · recommended by 122 people · 23 of 145 people were critical
  89. 89
    Think and Grow Rich
    Napoleon Hill · 1937 · recommended by 81 people · 15 of 96 people were critical
  90. 90
    The Name of the Wind
    Patrick Rothfuss · 2007 · recommended by 60 people · 11 of 71 people were critical
  91. 91
    Dive into Python
    Mark Pilgrim · 2004 · recommended by 94 people · 17 of 111 people were critical
  92. 92
    Thinking, fast and slow
    Daniel Kahneman · 2011 · recommended by 455 people · 81 of 536 people were critical
  93. 93
    The Lean Startup
    Eric Ries · 2011 · recommended by 281 people · 50 of 331 people were critical
  94. 94
    Fahrenheit 451
    Ray Bradbury · 1953 · recommended by 63 people · 11 of 74 people were critical
  95. 95
    Principles
    Ray Dalio · 2017 · recommended by 75 people · 13 of 88 people were critical
  96. 96
    Slaughterhouse-Five
    Kurt Vonnegut · 1969 · recommended by 58 people · 10 of 68 people were critical
  97. 97
    Gödel, Escher, Bach
    Douglas R. Hofstadter · 1979 · recommended by 505 people · 86 of 591 people were critical
  98. 98
    Head First design patterns
    Eric Freeman · 2004 · recommended by 65 people · 11 of 76 people were critical
  99. 99
    The Diamond Age
    Neal Stephenson · 1995 · recommended by 284 people · 48 of 332 people were critical
  100. 100
    Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?
    Philip K. Dick · 1968 · recommended by 66 people · 11 of 77 people were critical
  101. 101
    12 Rules for Life
    Jordan B. Peterson · 2018 · recommended by 61 people · 10 of 71 people were critical
  102. 102
    Dune
    Frank Herbert · 1965 · recommended by 193 people · 31 of 224 people were critical
  103. 103
    Cryptonomicon
    Neal Stephenson · 1999 · recommended by 324 people · 52 of 376 people were critical
  104. 104
    The Body Keeps the Score
    Bessel van der Kolk · 2014 · recommended by 90 people · 14 of 104 people were critical
  105. 105
    Superintelligence
    Nick Bostrom · 2014 · recommended by 92 people · 14 of 106 people were critical
  106. 106
    The Brothers Karamazov
    Fiódor Dostoievski · 2015 · recommended by 86 people · 13 of 99 people were critical
  107. 107
    Sapiens
    Yuval Noah Harari · 2011 · recommended by 201 people · 30 of 231 people were critical
  108. 108
    Anna Karenina
    Louise Maude · 2012 · recommended by 67 people · 10 of 77 people were critical
  109. 109
    Antifragile
    Nassim Nicholas Taleb · 2012 · recommended by 135 people · 20 of 155 people were critical
  110. 110
    Gulag Archipelago
    Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn · 1973 · recommended by 77 people · 11 of 88 people were critical
  111. 111
    Use of Weapons
    Iain Banks · 1990 · recommended by 78 people · 11 of 89 people were critical
  112. 112
    Brave New World
    Aldous Huxley · 1932 · recommended by 202 people · 28 of 230 people were critical
  113. 113
    I Am a Strange Loop
    Douglas R. Hofstadter · 2007 · recommended by 101 people · 14 of 115 people were critical
  114. 114
    Learn Python the Hard Way
    Zed Shaw · 2011 · recommended by 246 people · 34 of 280 people were critical
  115. 115
    To Kill a Mockingbird
    Harper Lee · 1960 · recommended by 81 people · 11 of 92 people were critical
  116. 116
    The Master and Margarita
    Edward Kemp · 2004 · recommended by 74 people · 10 of 84 people were critical
  117. 117
    Code Complete
    Steve McConnell · 1993 · recommended by 393 people · 53 of 446 people were critical
  118. 118
    Rainbows End
    Vernor Vinge · 2006 · recommended by 112 people · 15 of 127 people were critical
  119. 119
    Blood Meridian
    Cormac McCarthy · 1985 · recommended by 105 people · 14 of 119 people were critical
  120. 120
    Mistborn
    Brandon Sanderson · 2006 · recommended by 94 people · 12 of 106 people were critical
  121. 121
    Animal Farm
    George Orwell · 1945 · recommended by 110 people · 14 of 124 people were critical
  122. 122
    The Selfish Gene
    Richard Dawkins · 1976 · recommended by 220 people · 28 of 248 people were critical
  123. 123
    Programming Perl
    Larry Wall · 1991 · recommended by 90 people · 11 of 101 people were critical
  124. 124
    Anathem
    Neal Stephenson · 2008 · recommended by 207 people · 25 of 232 people were critical
  125. 125
    The Dawn of Everything
    David Graeber · 2021 · recommended by 110 people · 13 of 123 people were critical
  126. 126
    The art of electronics
    Paul Horowitz · 1980 · recommended by 153 people · 18 of 171 people were critical
  127. 127
    Atomic Habits
    James Clear · 2018 · recommended by 191 people · 22 of 213 people were critical
  128. 128
    The player of games
    Iain Banks · 1988 · recommended by 114 people · 13 of 127 people were critical
  129. 129
    Land of Lisp
    Conrad Barski · 2010 · recommended by 124 people · 14 of 138 people were critical
  130. 130
    Practical Typography
    Matthew Butterick · 2013 · recommended by 98 people · 11 of 109 people were critical
  131. 131
    The Left Hand of Darkness
    Ursula K. Le Guin · 1969 · recommended by 118 people · 13 of 131 people were critical
  132. 132
    Deep Work
    Cal Newport · 2016 · recommended by 310 people · 33 of 343 people were critical
  133. 133
    The C Programming Language
    Brian W. Kernighan · 1978 · recommended by 246 people · 26 of 272 people were critical
  134. 134
    Project Hail Mary
    Andy Weir · 2021 · recommended by 131 people · 13 of 144 people were critical
  135. 135
    Zero to One
    Peter A. Thiel · 2014 · recommended by 166 people · 16 of 182 people were critical
  136. 136
    Domain-Driven Design
    Eric Evans · 2003 · recommended by 104 people · 10 of 114 people were critical
  137. 137
    The Innovator's Dilemma
    Clayton M. Christensen · 1997 · recommended by 148 people · 14 of 162 people were critical
  138. 138
    Economics in One Lesson
    Henry Hazlitt · 1946 · recommended by 107 people · 10 of 117 people were critical
  139. 139
    The Phoenix Project
    Gene Kim · 2013 · recommended by 166 people · 15 of 181 people were critical
  140. 140
    How to Win Friends and Influence People
    Dale Carnegie · 1936 · recommended by 579 people · 52 of 631 people were critical
  141. 141
    Debt
    David Graeber · 2011 · recommended by 182 people · 16 of 198 people were critical
  142. 142
    How to Design Programs
    Matthias Felleisen · 2001 · recommended by 277 people · 24 of 301 people were critical
  143. 143
    The Count of Monte Cristo
    Alexandre Dumas · 1844 · recommended by 128 people · 11 of 139 people were critical
  144. 144
    Starting strength
    Mark Rippetoe · 2011 · recommended by 191 people · 16 of 207 people were critical
  145. 145
    "Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman"
    Richard Phillips Feynman · 1985 · recommended by 190 people · 15 of 205 people were critical
  146. 146
    The Pragmatic Programmer
    Andy Hunt · 1999 · recommended by 353 people · 26 of 379 people were critical
  147. 147
    The Intelligent Investor
    Benjamin Graham · 1949 · recommended by 152 people · 11 of 163 people were critical
  148. 148
    Hyperion
    Dan Simmons · 1989 · recommended by 154 people · 11 of 165 people were critical
  149. 149
    The Rust Programming Language
    Steve Klabnik · 2018 · recommended by 170 people · 12 of 182 people were critical
  150. 150
    Don't Make Me Think
    Steve Krug · 2000 · recommended by 256 people · 17 of 273 people were critical

Other rankings