Most argued over books on Hacker News
This ranking picks out the 150 books, from 15,732 in the library, that draw the most disagreement. It measures recommenders and critics both, so a title ranks high when many commenters praise it and many others pan it. That makes it a good guide to contested reading. Fifty Shades of Grey, The Population Bomb and IQ and the wealth of nations lead the list. Bestselling thrillers, controversial science and race debates also appear, including The Da Vinci Code and The Bell Curve.
Recommenders and critics both: the top 150 of 15,732 books mentioned in Hacker News comments.
By region
- Programming and computer science 24
- Self-help, psychology and business books 20
- Science fiction novels 33
- Classic and literary fiction 25
- Politics, economics and society 13
- Minds, machines and the future 17
- Tech industry, hacking and security books 4
- Mathematics and physics 1
- Philosophy and ancient history 4
- Money and investing 4
- Food, cooking and nutrition 2
- Writing, design and web craft 3
The list
- 1
Fifty Shades of GreyE. L. James · 2011 · recommended by 1 person · 18 of 19 people were critical - 2
The Population BombPaul R. Ehrlich · 1968 · recommended by 1 person · 12 of 13 people were critical - 3
IQ and the wealth of nationsRichard Lynn · 2002 · recommended by 2 people · 14 of 16 people were critical - 4
The Da Vinci CodeDan Brown · 2003 · recommended by 6 people · 40 of 46 people were critical - 5
Mein KampfAdolf Hitler · 1925 · recommended by 15 people · 54 of 69 people were critical - 6
In search of excellenceThomas J. Peters · 1982 · recommended by 3 people · 10 of 13 people were critical - 7
Chariots of the gods?Erich von Däniken · 1968 · recommended by 3 people · 10 of 13 people were critical - 8
A new kind of scienceStephen Wolfram · 2002 · recommended by 44 people · 120 of 164 people were critical - 9
White FragilityRobin J. DiAngelo · 2018 · recommended by 10 people · 23 of 33 people were critical - 10
The bell curveRichard J. Herrnstein · 1994 · recommended by 6 people · 13 of 19 people were critical - 11
Digital FortressDan Brown · 1998 · recommended by 10 people · 14 of 24 people were critical - 12
Finnegan's wakeJames Joyce · 1939 · recommended by 16 people · 17 of 33 people were critical - 13
Atlas ShruggedAyn Rand · 1957 · recommended by 207 people · 208 of 415 people were critical - 14
Lord of the FliesWilliam Golding · 1954 · recommended by 32 people · 32 of 64 people were critical - 15
State of FearMichael Crichton · 2004 · recommended by 11 people · 11 of 22 people were critical - 16
Rich Dad, Poor DadRobert T. Kiyosaki · 1990 · recommended by 96 people · 89 of 185 people were critical - 17
The age of spiritual machinesRay Kurzweil · 1999 · recommended by 13 people · 11 of 24 people were critical - 18
The Mismeasure of ManStephen Jay Gould · 1981 · recommended by 22 people · 17 of 39 people were critical - 19
Silicon snake oilClifford Stoll · 1995 · recommended by 13 people · 10 of 23 people were critical - 20
Clean CodeRobert C. Martin · 2008 · recommended by 298 people · 212 of 510 people were critical - 21
Compilers, principles, techniques, and toolsAlfred V. Aho · 1986 · recommended by 195 people · 137 of 332 people were critical - 22
BlinkMalcolm Gladwell · 2005 · recommended by 29 people · 20 of 49 people were critical - 23
The Catcher in the RyeJ. D. Salinger · 1951 · recommended by 60 people · 41 of 101 people were critical - 24
Design PatternsErich Gamma · 1994 · recommended by 95 people · 63 of 158 people were critical - 25
Flash BoysMichael Lewis · 2014 · recommended by 76 people · 50 of 126 people were critical - 26
The China StudyT. Colin Campbell, PhD · 2005 · recommended by 30 people · 19 of 49 people were critical - 27
The Wheel of TimeRobert Jordan · 1990 · recommended by 57 people · 36 of 93 people were critical - 28
Consider PhlebasIain Banks · 1987 · recommended by 69 people · 42 of 111 people were critical - 29
The Great GatsbyF. Scott Fitzgerald · 1925 · recommended by 58 people · 34 of 92 people were critical - 30
Limits to GrowthDonella H. Meadows · 1972 · recommended by 19 people · 10 of 29 people were critical - 31
The Singularity Is NearRay Kurzweil · 2005 · recommended by 30 people · 15 of 45 people were critical - 32
The SilmarillionJ.R.R. Tolkien · 1977 · recommended by 28 people · 14 of 42 people were critical - 33
ReamdeNeal Stephenson · 2011 · recommended by 56 people · 27 of 83 people were critical - 34
UlyssesJames Joyce · 1922 · recommended by 46 people · 21 of 67 people were critical - 35
Das KapitalKarl Marx · 1867 · recommended by 40 people · 18 of 58 people were critical - 36
The God DelusionRichard Dawkins · 2006 · recommended by 41 people · 18 of 59 people were critical - 37
The Origin of SpeciesCharles Darwin · 2002 · recommended by 30 people · 13 of 43 people were critical - 38
Emperor's New MindRoger Penrose · 1989 · recommended by 37 people · 15 of 52 people were critical - 39
Communist ManifestoKarl Marx · 1848 · recommended by 31 people · 12 of 43 people were critical - 40
Good to GreatCollins, James C. · 2001 · recommended by 71 people · 27 of 98 people were critical - 41
Moby DickHerman Melville · 1851 · recommended by 119 people · 45 of 164 people were critical - 42
Ready Player OneErnest Cline · 2011 · recommended by 123 people · 46 of 169 people were critical - 43
The Shock DoctrineNaomi Klein · 2007 · recommended by 27 people · 10 of 37 people were critical - 44
The Dark TowerStephen King · 2004 · recommended by 27 people · 10 of 37 people were critical - 45
Three felonies a dayHarvey A. Silverglate · 2009 · recommended by 33 people · 12 of 45 people were critical - 46
The 48 Laws of PowerRobert Greene · 1998 · recommended by 85 people · 30 of 115 people were critical - 47
Gravity's RainbowThomas Pynchon · 1973 · recommended by 58 people · 20 of 78 people were critical - 48
Clean ArchitectureRobert C. Martin · 2017 · recommended by 47 people · 16 of 63 people were critical - 49
SevenevesNeal Stephenson · 2015 · recommended by 188 people · 63 of 251 people were critical - 50
FoundationIsaac Asimov · 1951 · recommended by 143 people · 47 of 190 people were critical - 51
Guns, Germs, and SteelJared Diamond · 1997 · recommended by 214 people · 70 of 284 people were critical - 52
Termination ShockNeal Stephenson · 2021 · recommended by 34 people · 11 of 45 people were critical - 53
Stranger in a Strange LandRobert A. Heinlein · 1961 · recommended by 97 people · 31 of 128 people were critical - 54
Cracking The Coding InterviewGayle Laakmann McDowell · 2010 · recommended by 178 people · 54 of 232 people were critical - 55
Why We SleepMatthew P. Walker · 2017 · recommended by 202 people · 60 of 262 people were critical - 56
Homo DeusYuval Noah Harari · 2015 · recommended by 44 people · 13 of 57 people were critical - 57
The Ministry for the FutureKim Stanley Robinson · 2020 · recommended by 69 people · 20 of 89 people were critical - 58
OutliersMalcolm Gladwell · 2008 · recommended by 99 people · 28 of 127 people were critical - 59
The FountainheadAyn Rand · 1943 · recommended by 64 people · 18 of 82 people were critical - 60
Harry PotterJ. K. Rowling · 2001 · recommended by 55 people · 15 of 70 people were critical - 61
The Elements of StyleWilliam Strunk, Jr. · 1918 · recommended by 131 people · 35 of 166 people were critical - 62
Steve JobsWalter Isaacson · 2011 · recommended by 64 people · 17 of 81 people were critical - 63
Old Man’s WarJohn Scalzi · 2005 · recommended by 42 people · 11 of 53 people were critical - 64
Learn C the hard wayZed Shaw · 2015 · recommended by 70 people · 18 of 88 people were critical - 65
The Black SwanNassim Nicholas Taleb · 2007 · recommended by 263 people · 67 of 330 people were critical - 66
Bullshit JobsDavid Graeber · 2018 · recommended by 153 people · 38 of 191 people were critical - 67
Introduction to AlgorithmsThomas H. Cormen · 1990 · recommended by 274 people · 67 of 341 people were critical - 68
The art of computer programmingDonald Knuth · 1968 · recommended by 336 people · 82 of 418 people were critical - 69
Baroque CycleNeal Stephenson · 2003 · recommended by 115 people · 28 of 143 people were critical - 70
Applied CryptographyBruce Schneier · 1994 · recommended by 76 people · 18 of 94 people were critical - 71
Ender's GameOrson Scott Card · 1985 · recommended by 169 people · 40 of 209 people were critical - 72
Three-Body ProblemCixin Liu · 2006 · recommended by 233 people · 55 of 288 people were critical - 73
Infinite JestDavid Foster Wallace · 1996 · recommended by 145 people · 34 of 179 people were critical - 74
Effective Modern C++Scott Meyers · 2014 · recommended by 63 people · 14 of 77 people were critical - 75
A History of Western PhilosophyBertrand Russell · 1945 · recommended by 64 people · 14 of 78 people were critical - 76
Harry Potter and the Methods of RationalityEliezer Yudkowsky · 2010 · recommended by 170 people · 37 of 207 people were critical - 77
The Coddling of the American MindGreg Lukianoff · 2018 · recommended by 51 people · 11 of 62 people were critical - 78
Snow CrashNeal Stephenson · 1992 · recommended by 364 people · 77 of 441 people were critical - 79
The better angels of our natureSteven Pinker · 2011 · recommended by 72 people · 15 of 87 people were critical - 80
The Cathedral and the BazaarEric S. Raymond · 1999 · recommended by 72 people · 15 of 87 people were critical - 81
War and PeaceLev Tolstoi · 1845 · recommended by 78 people · 16 of 94 people were critical - 82
The Glass Bead GameHermann Hesse · 1943 · recommended by 51 people · 10 of 61 people were critical - 83
RingworldLarry Niven · 1970 · recommended by 51 people · 10 of 61 people were critical - 84
NeuromancerWilliam Gibson · 1984 · recommended by 296 people · 58 of 354 people were critical - 85
Crime and punishment1984 · recommended by 113 people · 22 of 135 people were critical - 86
Starship TroopersRobert A. Heinlein · 1959 · recommended by 57 people · 11 of 68 people were critical - 87
Learn You a Haskell for Great Good!Miran Lipovača · 2011 · recommended by 237 people · 45 of 282 people were critical - 88
Real World HaskellBryan O'Sullivan · 2008 · recommended by 122 people · 23 of 145 people were critical - 89
Think and Grow RichNapoleon Hill · 1937 · recommended by 81 people · 15 of 96 people were critical - 90
The Name of the WindPatrick Rothfuss · 2007 · recommended by 60 people · 11 of 71 people were critical - 91
Dive into PythonMark Pilgrim · 2004 · recommended by 94 people · 17 of 111 people were critical - 92
Thinking, fast and slowDaniel Kahneman · 2011 · recommended by 455 people · 81 of 536 people were critical - 93
The Lean StartupEric Ries · 2011 · recommended by 281 people · 50 of 331 people were critical - 94
Fahrenheit 451Ray Bradbury · 1953 · recommended by 63 people · 11 of 74 people were critical - 95
PrinciplesRay Dalio · 2017 · recommended by 75 people · 13 of 88 people were critical - 96
Slaughterhouse-FiveKurt Vonnegut · 1969 · recommended by 58 people · 10 of 68 people were critical - 97
Gödel, Escher, BachDouglas R. Hofstadter · 1979 · recommended by 505 people · 86 of 591 people were critical - 98
Head First design patternsEric Freeman · 2004 · recommended by 65 people · 11 of 76 people were critical - 99
The Diamond AgeNeal Stephenson · 1995 · recommended by 284 people · 48 of 332 people were critical - 100
Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?Philip K. Dick · 1968 · recommended by 66 people · 11 of 77 people were critical - 101
12 Rules for LifeJordan B. Peterson · 2018 · recommended by 61 people · 10 of 71 people were critical - 102
DuneFrank Herbert · 1965 · recommended by 193 people · 31 of 224 people were critical - 103
CryptonomiconNeal Stephenson · 1999 · recommended by 324 people · 52 of 376 people were critical - 104
The Body Keeps the ScoreBessel van der Kolk · 2014 · recommended by 90 people · 14 of 104 people were critical - 105
SuperintelligenceNick Bostrom · 2014 · recommended by 92 people · 14 of 106 people were critical - 106
The Brothers KaramazovFiódor Dostoievski · 2015 · recommended by 86 people · 13 of 99 people were critical - 107
SapiensYuval Noah Harari · 2011 · recommended by 201 people · 30 of 231 people were critical - 108
Anna KareninaLouise Maude · 2012 · recommended by 67 people · 10 of 77 people were critical - 109
AntifragileNassim Nicholas Taleb · 2012 · recommended by 135 people · 20 of 155 people were critical - 110
Gulag ArchipelagoAleksandr Solzhenitsyn · 1973 · recommended by 77 people · 11 of 88 people were critical - 111
Use of WeaponsIain Banks · 1990 · recommended by 78 people · 11 of 89 people were critical - 112
Brave New WorldAldous Huxley · 1932 · recommended by 202 people · 28 of 230 people were critical - 113
I Am a Strange LoopDouglas R. Hofstadter · 2007 · recommended by 101 people · 14 of 115 people were critical - 114
Learn Python the Hard WayZed Shaw · 2011 · recommended by 246 people · 34 of 280 people were critical - 115
To Kill a MockingbirdHarper Lee · 1960 · recommended by 81 people · 11 of 92 people were critical - 116
The Master and MargaritaEdward Kemp · 2004 · recommended by 74 people · 10 of 84 people were critical - 117
Code CompleteSteve McConnell · 1993 · recommended by 393 people · 53 of 446 people were critical - 118
Rainbows EndVernor Vinge · 2006 · recommended by 112 people · 15 of 127 people were critical - 119
Blood MeridianCormac McCarthy · 1985 · recommended by 105 people · 14 of 119 people were critical - 120
MistbornBrandon Sanderson · 2006 · recommended by 94 people · 12 of 106 people were critical - 121
Animal FarmGeorge Orwell · 1945 · recommended by 110 people · 14 of 124 people were critical - 122
The Selfish GeneRichard Dawkins · 1976 · recommended by 220 people · 28 of 248 people were critical - 123
Programming PerlLarry Wall · 1991 · recommended by 90 people · 11 of 101 people were critical - 124
AnathemNeal Stephenson · 2008 · recommended by 207 people · 25 of 232 people were critical - 125
The Dawn of EverythingDavid Graeber · 2021 · recommended by 110 people · 13 of 123 people were critical - 126
The art of electronicsPaul Horowitz · 1980 · recommended by 153 people · 18 of 171 people were critical - 127
Atomic HabitsJames Clear · 2018 · recommended by 191 people · 22 of 213 people were critical - 128
The player of gamesIain Banks · 1988 · recommended by 114 people · 13 of 127 people were critical - 129
Land of LispConrad Barski · 2010 · recommended by 124 people · 14 of 138 people were critical - 130
Practical TypographyMatthew Butterick · 2013 · recommended by 98 people · 11 of 109 people were critical - 131
The Left Hand of DarknessUrsula K. Le Guin · 1969 · recommended by 118 people · 13 of 131 people were critical - 132
Deep WorkCal Newport · 2016 · recommended by 310 people · 33 of 343 people were critical - 133
The C Programming LanguageBrian W. Kernighan · 1978 · recommended by 246 people · 26 of 272 people were critical - 134
Project Hail MaryAndy Weir · 2021 · recommended by 131 people · 13 of 144 people were critical - 135
Zero to OnePeter A. Thiel · 2014 · recommended by 166 people · 16 of 182 people were critical - 136
Domain-Driven DesignEric Evans · 2003 · recommended by 104 people · 10 of 114 people were critical - 137
The Innovator's DilemmaClayton M. Christensen · 1997 · recommended by 148 people · 14 of 162 people were critical - 138
Economics in One LessonHenry Hazlitt · 1946 · recommended by 107 people · 10 of 117 people were critical - 139
The Phoenix ProjectGene Kim · 2013 · recommended by 166 people · 15 of 181 people were critical - 140
How to Win Friends and Influence PeopleDale Carnegie · 1936 · recommended by 579 people · 52 of 631 people were critical - 141
DebtDavid Graeber · 2011 · recommended by 182 people · 16 of 198 people were critical - 142
How to Design ProgramsMatthias Felleisen · 2001 · recommended by 277 people · 24 of 301 people were critical - 143
The Count of Monte CristoAlexandre Dumas · 1844 · recommended by 128 people · 11 of 139 people were critical - 144
Starting strengthMark Rippetoe · 2011 · recommended by 191 people · 16 of 207 people were critical - 145
"Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman"Richard Phillips Feynman · 1985 · recommended by 190 people · 15 of 205 people were critical - 146
The Pragmatic ProgrammerAndy Hunt · 1999 · recommended by 353 people · 26 of 379 people were critical - 147
The Intelligent InvestorBenjamin Graham · 1949 · recommended by 152 people · 11 of 163 people were critical - 148
HyperionDan Simmons · 1989 · recommended by 154 people · 11 of 165 people were critical - 149
The Rust Programming LanguageSteve Klabnik · 2018 · recommended by 170 people · 12 of 182 people were critical - 150
Don't Make Me ThinkSteve Krug · 2000 · recommended by 256 people · 17 of 273 people were critical
Other rankings
- Most recommended distinct people who recommended it
- Most loved share of mentions that recommend
- Evergreen recommended steadily across the years
- Rising more people in the last 90 days than before
- Hype a burst in one year and quiet since
- Most argued over recommenders and critics both
- Sleeper hits few people, all of them warm