DeepRead

Most argued over books on Science fiction novels, according to Hacker News

This ranking looks at the science fiction novels that Hacker News commenters both recommend and criticize, so it surfaces books that split opinion rather than ones everyone agrees on. Across 33 books, Michael Crichton's State of Fear leads, followed by Robert Jordan's The Wheel of Time and Iain Banks's Consider Phlebas. Neal Stephenson's Reamde, Seveneves and Termination Shock also appear, along with classics like Asimov's Foundation. Long, ambitious, popular works dominate the list.

Recommenders and critics both: 33 books from Science fiction novels in the library-wide Most argued over list.

  1. 1
    State of Fear
    Michael Crichton · 2004 · recommended by 11 people · 11 of 22 people were critical
  2. 2
    The Wheel of Time
    Robert Jordan · 1990 · recommended by 57 people · 36 of 93 people were critical
  3. 3
    Consider Phlebas
    Iain Banks · 1987 · recommended by 69 people · 42 of 111 people were critical
  4. 4
    Reamde
    Neal Stephenson · 2011 · recommended by 56 people · 27 of 83 people were critical
  5. 5
    Ready Player One
    Ernest Cline · 2011 · recommended by 123 people · 46 of 169 people were critical
  6. 6
    The Dark Tower
    Stephen King · 2004 · recommended by 27 people · 10 of 37 people were critical
  7. 7
    Seveneves
    Neal Stephenson · 2015 · recommended by 188 people · 63 of 251 people were critical
  8. 8
    Foundation
    Isaac Asimov · 1951 · recommended by 143 people · 47 of 190 people were critical
  9. 9
    Termination Shock
    Neal Stephenson · 2021 · recommended by 34 people · 11 of 45 people were critical
  10. 10
    Stranger in a Strange Land
    Robert A. Heinlein · 1961 · recommended by 97 people · 31 of 128 people were critical
  11. 11
    The Ministry for the Future
    Kim Stanley Robinson · 2020 · recommended by 69 people · 20 of 89 people were critical
  12. 12
    Old Man’s War
    John Scalzi · 2005 · recommended by 42 people · 11 of 53 people were critical
  13. 13
    Baroque Cycle
    Neal Stephenson · 2003 · recommended by 115 people · 28 of 143 people were critical
  14. 14
    Ender's Game
    Orson Scott Card · 1985 · recommended by 169 people · 40 of 209 people were critical
  15. 15
    Three-Body Problem
    Cixin Liu · 2006 · recommended by 233 people · 55 of 288 people were critical
  16. 16
    Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality
    Eliezer Yudkowsky · 2010 · recommended by 170 people · 37 of 207 people were critical
  17. 17
    Snow Crash
    Neal Stephenson · 1992 · recommended by 364 people · 77 of 441 people were critical
  18. 18
    Ringworld
    Larry Niven · 1970 · recommended by 51 people · 10 of 61 people were critical
  19. 19
    Neuromancer
    William Gibson · 1984 · recommended by 296 people · 58 of 354 people were critical
  20. 20
    Starship Troopers
    Robert A. Heinlein · 1959 · recommended by 57 people · 11 of 68 people were critical
  21. 21
    The Name of the Wind
    Patrick Rothfuss · 2007 · recommended by 60 people · 11 of 71 people were critical
  22. 22
    The Diamond Age
    Neal Stephenson · 1995 · recommended by 284 people · 48 of 332 people were critical
  23. 23
    Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?
    Philip K. Dick · 1968 · recommended by 66 people · 11 of 77 people were critical
  24. 24
    Dune
    Frank Herbert · 1965 · recommended by 193 people · 31 of 224 people were critical
  25. 25
    Cryptonomicon
    Neal Stephenson · 1999 · recommended by 324 people · 52 of 376 people were critical
  26. 26
    Use of Weapons
    Iain Banks · 1990 · recommended by 78 people · 11 of 89 people were critical
  27. 27
    Rainbows End
    Vernor Vinge · 2006 · recommended by 112 people · 15 of 127 people were critical
  28. 28
    Mistborn
    Brandon Sanderson · 2006 · recommended by 94 people · 12 of 106 people were critical
  29. 29
    Anathem
    Neal Stephenson · 2008 · recommended by 207 people · 25 of 232 people were critical
  30. 30
    The player of games
    Iain Banks · 1988 · recommended by 114 people · 13 of 127 people were critical
  31. 31
    The Left Hand of Darkness
    Ursula K. Le Guin · 1969 · recommended by 118 people · 13 of 131 people were critical
  32. 32
    Project Hail Mary
    Andy Weir · 2021 · recommended by 131 people · 13 of 144 people were critical
  33. 33
    Hyperion
    Dan Simmons · 1989 · recommended by 154 people · 11 of 165 people were critical

Rankings in Science fiction novels