DeepRead

Most argued over books on Classic and literary fiction, according to Hacker News

This ranking looks at the books in classic and literary fiction that Hacker News commenters both recommend and criticize, so the most argued-over titles rise to the top. Of the 25 books here, the leaders mix pop blockbusters like Fifty Shades of Grey and The Da Vinci Code with demanding modernist works such as Finnegan's Wake. Lord of the Flies and The Catcher in the Rye also rank high, which shows how divisive even well-known canonical books can be.

Recommenders and critics both: 25 books from Classic and literary fiction in the library-wide Most argued over list.

  1. 1
    Fifty Shades of Grey
    E. L. James · 2011 · recommended by 1 person · 18 of 19 people were critical
  2. 2
    The Da Vinci Code
    Dan Brown · 2003 · recommended by 6 people · 40 of 46 people were critical
  3. 3
    Finnegan's wake
    James Joyce · 1939 · recommended by 16 people · 17 of 33 people were critical
  4. 4
    Lord of the Flies
    William Golding · 1954 · recommended by 32 people · 32 of 64 people were critical
  5. 5
    The Catcher in the Rye
    J. D. Salinger · 1951 · recommended by 60 people · 41 of 101 people were critical
  6. 6
    The Great Gatsby
    F. Scott Fitzgerald · 1925 · recommended by 58 people · 34 of 92 people were critical
  7. 7
    The Silmarillion
    J.R.R. Tolkien · 1977 · recommended by 28 people · 14 of 42 people were critical
  8. 8
    Ulysses
    James Joyce · 1922 · recommended by 46 people · 21 of 67 people were critical
  9. 9
    Moby Dick
    Herman Melville · 1851 · recommended by 119 people · 45 of 164 people were critical
  10. 10
    Gravity's Rainbow
    Thomas Pynchon · 1973 · recommended by 58 people · 20 of 78 people were critical
  11. 11
    Harry Potter
    J. K. Rowling · 2001 · recommended by 55 people · 15 of 70 people were critical
  12. 12
    Infinite Jest
    David Foster Wallace · 1996 · recommended by 145 people · 34 of 179 people were critical
  13. 13
    War and Peace
    Lev Tolstoi · 1845 · recommended by 78 people · 16 of 94 people were critical
  14. 14
    Crime and punishment
    1984 · recommended by 113 people · 22 of 135 people were critical
  15. 15
    Fahrenheit 451
    Ray Bradbury · 1953 · recommended by 63 people · 11 of 74 people were critical
  16. 16
    Slaughterhouse-Five
    Kurt Vonnegut · 1969 · recommended by 58 people · 10 of 68 people were critical
  17. 17
    The Brothers Karamazov
    Fiódor Dostoievski · 2015 · recommended by 86 people · 13 of 99 people were critical
  18. 18
    Anna Karenina
    Louise Maude · 2012 · recommended by 67 people · 10 of 77 people were critical
  19. 19
    Gulag Archipelago
    Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn · 1973 · recommended by 77 people · 11 of 88 people were critical
  20. 20
    Brave New World
    Aldous Huxley · 1932 · recommended by 202 people · 28 of 230 people were critical
  21. 21
    To Kill a Mockingbird
    Harper Lee · 1960 · recommended by 81 people · 11 of 92 people were critical
  22. 22
    The Master and Margarita
    Edward Kemp · 2004 · recommended by 74 people · 10 of 84 people were critical
  23. 23
    Blood Meridian
    Cormac McCarthy · 1985 · recommended by 105 people · 14 of 119 people were critical
  24. 24
    Animal Farm
    George Orwell · 1945 · recommended by 110 people · 14 of 124 people were critical
  25. 25
    The Count of Monte Cristo
    Alexandre Dumas · 1844 · recommended by 128 people · 11 of 139 people were critical

Rankings in Classic and literary fiction