DeepRead
Cover of The Origins of Reasonable Doubt

The Origins of Reasonable Doubt

James Q. Whitman · 2008

Philosophy and ancient history › Philosophy of science

#15,002 most recommended

About the book

The book is a history of the reasonable doubt standard that governs criminal convictions in the United States and England. It traces how the rule developed from Christian moral theology and the common-law trial practice that absorbed it, drawing mainly on English and American sources from the medieval period onward. Whitman argues that reasonable doubt began as a theological safeguard for jurors rather than as a rule protecting the accused. Under Christian teaching, a juror who convicted an innocent defendant while still doubting risked mortal sin, so the doctrine assured jurors they were safe as long as their doubts were not reasonable. He contends that the rule was later reinterpreted as a defendant protection and now serves different purposes, leaving jurors confused about what it requires. He presents this gap between the rule's origins and its present use as a serious moral problem for the justice system.

Written by Claude from what it knows of this book.

What Hacker News says 100% recommend · 0% critical

01220212022202320242021 peak · 1
This bookAverage book in Philosophy of science

In the commenters’ own words

What Open Library readers say

No Open Library reader has rated it yet.

  • 1 want to read
  • 0 reading
  • 0 have read

Open Library’s page for the book

What critics say, via Wikipedia

No Wikipedia article about this book yet, so no critics to quote.

Reddit communities — coming later

The threads it came up in

Details

First published
2008
ISBN
9780300116007
Editions known
2 at Open Library
Open Library
OL4752676W

Burden of proofCriminal EvidenceCriminal JudgmentsHistoryLaw, united states, historyMoral and ethical aspectsReligion and law

Explore in the mosaic

Read next: its neighbours on the mosaic

  • The Medieval Origins of the Legal Profession
    James A. Brundage · 2008 · recommended by 2 people · 2 people recommended both
  • Inventing the Individual
    Larry Siedentop · 2014 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
  • The Second Amendment
    Michael Waldman · 2014 · recommended by 1 person · loosely similar by subject
  • Ancient Greek Law in the 21st Century
    Paula Perlman · 2018 · recommended by 3 people · 2 people recommended both
  • Reasonable faith
    William Lane Craig · 1994 · recommended by 4 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • Evidence that demands a verdict
    Josh McDowell · 1972 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • Jesus and John Wayne
    Kristin Kobes Du Mez · 2020 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
  • The nothing that is
    Kaplan, Robert · 1999 · recommended by 4 people · loosely similar by subject
  • Dominion
    Tom Holland · 2019 · recommended by 20 people · loosely similar by subject
  • Whose Justice? Which Rationality?
    Alasdair C. MacIntyre · 1988 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • On certainty =
    Ludwig Wittgenstein · 1969 · recommended by 5 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • Aristotle's Revenge
    Edward Feser · 2019 · recommended by 3 people · loosely similar by subject
  • The will to believe
    William James · 1897 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • The Reason for God
    Timothy J. Keller · 2008 · recommended by 5 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • Understanding arguments
    Robert J. Fogelin · 1978 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • Devil Take the Hindmost
    Edward Chancellor · 1999 · recommended by 12 people · loosely similar by subject
  • The Collapse of American Criminal Justice
    William J. Stuntz · 2011 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • A Grief Observed
    C. S. Lewis · 1961 · recommended by 5 people · loosely similar by subject
  • Proving history
    Richard Carrier · 2012 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • The Common Law
    Oliver Wendell Holmes · 1881 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it
  • Case for Christ
    Lee Strobel · 1998 · recommended by 8 people · loosely similar by subject
  • The Age of Reason
    Thomas Paine · 1794 · recommended by 6 people · loosely similar by subject
  • Asking the right questions
    M. Neil Browne · 1981 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
  • ENIAC
    Scott McCartney · 1999 · recommended by 7 people · loosely similar by subject