
The Origins of Reasonable Doubt
James Q. Whitman · 2008
Philosophy and ancient history › Philosophy of science
#15,002 most recommended
Hacker News
2
mentions by 2 people · top 79% of 15,732 books
Open Library
—
No ratings yet
1 want to read
Wikipedia
—
No article yet
About the book
The book is a history of the reasonable doubt standard that governs criminal convictions in the United States and England. It traces how the rule developed from Christian moral theology and the common-law trial practice that absorbed it, drawing mainly on English and American sources from the medieval period onward. Whitman argues that reasonable doubt began as a theological safeguard for jurors rather than as a rule protecting the accused. Under Christian teaching, a juror who convicted an innocent defendant while still doubting risked mortal sin, so the doctrine assured jurors they were safe as long as their doubts were not reasonable. He contends that the rule was later reinterpreted as a defendant protection and now serves different purposes, leaving jurors confused about what it requires. He presents this gap between the rule's origins and its present use as a serious moral problem for the justice system.
Written by Claude from what it knows of this book.
What Hacker News says 100% recommend · 0% critical
In the commenters’ own words
> You can try that argument but it's not very convincing. I think you could do equally well arguing that slavery is the fault of Christianity […] You can also…
The medieval origins of the legal profession: canonists, civilians, and courts by Brundage The origins of reasonable doubt: theological roots of the criminal…
What Open Library readers say
No Open Library reader has rated it yet.
- 1 want to read
- 0 reading
- 0 have read
What critics say, via Wikipedia
No Wikipedia article about this book yet, so no critics to quote.
Reddit communities — coming later
The threads it came up in
Details
- First published
- 2008
- ISBN
- 9780300116007
- Editions known
- 2 at Open Library
- Open Library
- OL4752676W
Burden of proofCriminal EvidenceCriminal JudgmentsHistoryLaw, united states, historyMoral and ethical aspectsReligion and law
Read next: its neighbours on the mosaic
The Medieval Origins of the Legal ProfessionJames A. Brundage · 2008 · recommended by 2 people · 2 people recommended both
Inventing the IndividualLarry Siedentop · 2014 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
The Second AmendmentMichael Waldman · 2014 · recommended by 1 person · loosely similar by subject
Ancient Greek Law in the 21st CenturyPaula Perlman · 2018 · recommended by 3 people · 2 people recommended both
Reasonable faithWilliam Lane Craig · 1994 · recommended by 4 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Evidence that demands a verdictJosh McDowell · 1972 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Jesus and John WayneKristin Kobes Du Mez · 2020 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
The nothing that isKaplan, Robert · 1999 · recommended by 4 people · loosely similar by subject
DominionTom Holland · 2019 · recommended by 20 people · loosely similar by subject
Whose Justice? Which Rationality?Alasdair C. MacIntyre · 1988 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
On certainty =Ludwig Wittgenstein · 1969 · recommended by 5 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Aristotle's RevengeEdward Feser · 2019 · recommended by 3 people · loosely similar by subject
The will to believeWilliam James · 1897 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Reason for GodTimothy J. Keller · 2008 · recommended by 5 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Understanding argumentsRobert J. Fogelin · 1978 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it
Devil Take the HindmostEdward Chancellor · 1999 · recommended by 12 people · loosely similar by subject
The Collapse of American Criminal JusticeWilliam J. Stuntz · 2011 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
A Grief ObservedC. S. Lewis · 1961 · recommended by 5 people · loosely similar by subject
Proving historyRichard Carrier · 2012 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Common LawOliver Wendell Holmes · 1881 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it
Case for ChristLee Strobel · 1998 · recommended by 8 people · loosely similar by subject
The Age of ReasonThomas Paine · 1794 · recommended by 6 people · loosely similar by subject
Asking the right questionsM. Neil Browne · 1981 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
ENIACScott McCartney · 1999 · recommended by 7 people · loosely similar by subject