
Proving history
Richard Carrier · 2012
Machine learning, statistics and probability › Probability, causality and information theory
#7,885 most recommended
Hacker News
5
mentions by 4 people · top 48% of 15,732 books
Open Library
3.67★★★★★★★★★★
3 ratings · 3 want to read
Wikipedia
—
No article yet
About the book
A methodological work on how historians should reason about evidence from the ancient past, with New Testament scholarship and the historicity of Jesus as its main case. It covers the history of historical method and the limits of the criteria that scholars traditionally use to judge the reliability of sources. Carrier argues that Bayes's theorem should replace the traditional criteria of authenticity as the proper framework for historical inference, since it makes explicit how prior probabilities and evidence combine. He applies this framework to the question of whether Jesus existed and concludes that the case for a historical Jesus is considerably weaker than mainstream scholarship assumes. He also contends that the existing evidence fits a mythicist hypothesis about as well as the standard view.
Written by Claude from what it knows of this book.
What Hacker News says 50% recommend · 0% critical
In the commenters’ own words
> I have no idea what he meant. I do not have ESP, and given that Chesterton is long dead, it probably wouldn't be effective even if I did. An author writes…
> You really believe that is what Chesterton meant? I have no idea what he meant. I do not have ESP, and given that Chesterton is long dead, it probably…
What Open Library readers say 3.67 from 3 ratings
- 51
- 41
- 30
- 21
- 10
- 3 want to read
- 0 reading
- 4 have read
Only 3 ratings: treat the average as a hint.
What critics say, via Wikipedia
No Wikipedia article about this book yet, so no critics to quote.
Reddit communities — coming later
Details
- First published
- 2012
- ISBN
- 9781616145590
- Editions known
- 2 at Open Library
- Open Library
- OL16451412W
Bayesian statistical decision theoryHistoricityHistoricity of Jesus ChristJesus Christ -- HistoricityJesus christ, historicity
Read next: its neighbours on the mosaic
Did Jesus Exist?Bart D. Ehrman · 2012 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Case for ChristLee Strobel · 1998 · recommended by 8 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Theory That Would Not DieSharon Bertsch McGrayne · 2011 · recommended by 14 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The quantum challengeGeorge Greenstein · 1997 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
Jesus before the GospelsBart D. Ehrman · 2016 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Evidence that demands a verdictJosh McDowell · 1972 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
HistoryAnatoly Fomenko · 2003 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it
Probability TheoryE. T. Jaynes · 2003 · recommended by 77 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Natural theologyWilliam Paley · 1802 · recommended by 0 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Return of the God HypothesisStephen C. Meyer · 1920 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
CausalityJudea Pearl · 2000 · recommended by 17 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Why evolution is trueJerry A. Coyne · 2009 · recommended by 9 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Physics and philosophyWerner Heisenberg · 1958 · recommended by 6 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Bernoulli's FallacyAubrey Clayton · 2021 · recommended by 4 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
MathematicsMorris Kline · 1980 · recommended by 6 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Reasonable faithWilliam Lane Craig · 1994 · recommended by 4 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Book of WhyJudea Pearl · 2018 · recommended by 59 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Emergence of ProbabilityIan Hacking · 1975 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Chariots of the gods?Erich von Däniken · 1968 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The God DelusionRichard Dawkins · 2006 · recommended by 41 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The fabric of realityDavid Deutsch · 1997 · recommended by 23 people · loosely similar by subject
The last superstitionEdward Feser · 2008 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Origins of Reasonable DoubtJames Q. Whitman · 2008 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Mismeasure of ManStephen Jay Gould · 1981 · recommended by 22 people · loosely similar by subject