
Proofs and refutations
Imre Lakatos, John Worrall, Elie Zahar · 1976
Mathematics and physics › Mathematical philosophy and logic
#920 most recommended
Hacker News
55
mentions by 45 people · top 6% of 15,732 books
Open Library
4.00★★★★★★★★★★
1 rating · 23 want to read
Wikipedia
1,022
article views a month
About the book
The book follows one theorem, Euler's relation V − E + F = 2 for polyhedra, through a classroom dialogue among students and a teacher. It treats the methodology, philosophy and history of mathematics, with notes tracing parallel episodes from the history of the subject. Lakatos contends that mathematical knowledge grows through a dialectic of conjecture, counterexample and revised concepts, not through deduction from fixed axioms to certain truths. Counterexamples do not simply refute a theorem; they prompt changes to definitions, proofs and the scope of concepts, through strategies such as exception-barring and monster-barring. The book argues against formalist and naive deductivist accounts of mathematics and presents informal, heuristic reasoning as the real process by which proofs are found and improved.
Written by Claude from what it knows of this book.
What Hacker News says 76% recommend · 2% critical
In the commenters’ own words
We absolutely can do math in the face of some probability of being wrong about our proofs (and the proofs of our proof systems, and our proofs of the…
Here’s my (sometimes heavy-handed) restatement. The thesis is marked by asterisks. The author’s expression tends toward the literary and thus reduces clarity…
What Open Library readers say 4.00 from 1 rating
- 50
- 41
- 30
- 20
- 10
- 23 want to read
- 1 reading
- 2 have read
Only 1 rating: treat the average as a hint.
What Wikipedia says
- published 1976
- articles in 5 languages
- 1,022 views a month
Reddit communities — coming later
The threads it came up in
- Ask HN: Mind bending books to read and never be the same as before?
- Ask HN: Best books you read in 2012
- Ask HN: Which book can attract anyone towards your field of study?
- Ask HN: Recommend a maths book for a teenager?
- Ask HN: Math books that made you significantly better at math?
- Ask HN: Best Philosophical Books?
- Ask HN: Math books you recommend just for the way they are written?
- Philosophy of mathematics – a reading list (2020)
Details
- First published
- 1976
- ISBN
- 9780521290388
- Editions known
- 18 at Open Library
- Open Library
- OL2171423W
BeweistheorieFormalismus (Mathematik)KritikLogic, Symbolic and mathematicalMathematicsMathematics, philosophyMathematikMathematische LogikPhilosophiePhilosophySymbolic and mathematical Logic
Read next: its neighbours on the mosaic
Mathematical discoveryGeorge Pólya · 1962 · recommended by 2 people · named together in 3 comments
The world of mathematicsJames Roy Newman · 1956 · recommended by 9 people · 2 people recommended both
How to solve itGeorge Pólya · 1945 · recommended by 161 people · 5 people recommended both
The Mathematical ExperiencePhilip J. Davis · 1980 · recommended by 20 people · 2 people recommended both
What is mathematics?Richard Courant · 1941 · recommended by 45 people · 2 people recommended both
Proofs from the bookMartin Aigner · 1998 · recommended by 28 people · 2 people recommended both
What is mathematics, really?Reuben Hersh · 1997 · recommended by 4 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Against MethodPaul K. Feyerabend · 1975 · recommended by 32 people · named together in 4 comments
How to prove itDaniel J. Velleman · 1994 · recommended by 78 people · 2 people recommended both
Chapter ZeroCarol Schumacher · 1995 · recommended by 5 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Mathematics and plausible reasoningGeorge Pólya · 1954 · recommended by 10 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Journey Through GeniusWilliam Dunham · 1990 · recommended by 25 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Linear Algebra Done RightSheldon Jay Axler · 2004 · recommended by 130 people · 2 people recommended both
Philosophical investigationsLudwig Wittgenstein · 1953 · recommended by 42 people · 2 people recommended both
Book of ProofRichard Hammack · 2009 · recommended by 54 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Principia mathematicaAlfred North Whitehead · 1910 · recommended by 9 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
A Mathematician's LamentPaul Lockhart · 2009 · recommended by 47 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
A mathematician's apologyG. H. Hardy · 1940 · recommended by 30 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Gödel's proofErnest Nagel · 1958 · recommended by 30 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Critique of Pure ReasonImmanuel Kant · 1781 · recommended by 28 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Tractatus logico-philosophicusLudwig Wittgenstein · 1921 · recommended by 21 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Where Mathematics Comes FromGeorge Lakoff · 2000 · recommended by 18 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Introduction to Mathematical ThinkingKeith J. Devlin · 2012 · recommended by 16 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
A transition to advanced mathematicsSmith, Douglas · 1983 · recommended by 15 people · similar by subject and what people say about it