
The rejection of continental drift
Naomi Oreskes · 1999
Philosophy and ancient history › Philosophy of science
#13,610 most recommended
Hacker News
2
mentions by 2 people · top 79% of 15,732 books
Open Library
—
No ratings yet
Wikipedia
—
No article yet
About the book
The history of how geologists in the United States responded to Alfred Wegener's proposal that the continents have moved across the Earth's surface, roughly from the 1910s to the 1960s. It covers the scientific arguments, the people and institutions involved, and the evidence that eventually led to the acceptance of plate tectonics. Oreskes argues that American earth scientists rejected continental drift not only because the evidence was weak but because the theory failed their standards of sound geological method, which stressed inductive generalization from field observation and demanded a known causal mechanism. She contends that these standards and the ideal of verifiability were shaped by disciplinary values, so the rejection was a reasonable response to the norms of the time rather than a simple failure of reason. The book also holds that acceptance came only after geophysical evidence such as paleomagnetism and seafloor data changed what counted as adequate support, and it uses this case to question whether scientific consensus follows evidence in a straightforward way.
Written by Claude from what it knows of this book.
What Hacker News says 0% recommend · 0% critical
In the commenters’ own words
You couldn't be more wrong. I'll offer as an excellent case study in development and establishment of new scientific theory, the emergence of plate tectonics…
I think you are right, but this is a straw man. There are some quantum consciousness cults out there, but plenty of people are interested in investigating the…
What Open Library readers say
No Open Library reader has rated it yet.
What critics say, via Wikipedia
No Wikipedia article about this book yet, so no critics to quote.
Reddit communities — coming later
Details
- First published
- 1999
- ISBN
- 9780195117332
- Editions known
- 8 at Open Library
- Open Library
- OL1809229W
Continental driftGeologyGeology, united statesHistory
Read next: its neighbours on the mosaic
The End Of ScienceJohn Horgan · 2015 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it
The DeniersLawrence Solomon · 2008 · recommended by 1 person · loosely similar by subject
Merchants of DoubtNaomi Oreskes · 2010 · recommended by 32 people · loosely similar by subject
The Knowledge MachineMichael Strevens · 2020 · recommended by 0 people · loosely similar by subject
The war on scienceShawn Otto · 2016 · recommended by 1 person · loosely similar by subject
The shaky gameArthur Fine · 1986 · recommended by 1 person · loosely similar by subject
A troublesome inheritanceNicholas Wade · 2014 · recommended by 1 person · loosely similar by subject
The Republican War on ScienceChris C. Mooney · 2005 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
The Great DerangementAmitav Ghosh · 2016 · recommended by 1 person · loosely similar by subject
The big bang never happenedEric J. Lerner · 1991 · recommended by 0 people · loosely similar by subject
Tyranny of sciencePaul K. Feyerabend · 2011 · recommended by 1 person · loosely similar by subject
Higher superstitionNorman Levitt · 1997 · recommended by 0 people · loosely similar by subject
Unscientific AmericaChris C. Mooney · 2009 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
Not Even WrongPeter Woit · 2006 · recommended by 6 people · loosely similar by subject
The Copernican revolutionThomas S. Kuhn · 1957 · recommended by 7 people · loosely similar by subject
Under a Green SkyPeter Douglas Ward · 2007 · recommended by 7 people · loosely similar by subject
A dangerous placeMarc Reisner · 2003 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
Bad scienceGary Taubes · 1993 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
Mind and cosmosThomas Nagel · 2012 · recommended by 3 people · loosely similar by subject
SupercontinentTed Nield · 2007 · recommended by 2 people · loosely similar by subject
Higher SpeculationsHelge Kragh · 2011 · recommended by 1 person · loosely similar by subject
Chariots of the gods?Erich von Däniken · 1968 · recommended by 3 people · loosely similar by subject
The invention of scienceDavid Wootton · 2015 · recommended by 7 people · loosely similar by subject
Physics and philosophyWerner Heisenberg · 1958 · recommended by 6 people · loosely similar by subject