
Questioning collapse
Patricia Ann McAnany, Norman Yoffee · 2009
Minds, machines and the future › Big-picture human history
#8,910 most recommended
Hacker News
4
mentions by 4 people · top 54% of 15,732 books
Open Library
—
No ratings yet
5 want to read
Wikipedia
541
article views a month
About the book
An edited volume of essays by archaeologists and historians, co-edited by Patricia McAnany and Norman Yoffee, that examines the concept of societal collapse across many ancient civilizations, including the Maya, Mesopotamia, and Rome. Its scope covers how collapse is defined, studied, and narrated, and how ecological, political, and historical factors interact in a society's decline or transformation. The volume challenges the popular view that collapse is primarily caused by environmental mismanagement, a view associated with works such as Jared Diamond's Collapse. Its contributors argue that collapse is a contested category shaped by modern assumptions, including imperial and racialized framings of non-Western societies. They emphasize resilience and social reorganization over sudden disappearance, and they treat vulnerability as a product of political economy and inequality rather than of ecology alone.
Written by Claude from what it knows of this book.
What Hacker News says 25% recommend · 0% critical
In the commenters’ own words
As far as I'm aware, this has been thoroughly debunked, especially by Hunt and Lipo [1], who have argued against the "ecocide" theory, pointing out that the…
There are lots of books, papers, blogs, etc out there that offer refutations of people like Hancock. The SAA Archaeological Record dedicated an entire section…
What Open Library readers say
No Open Library reader has rated it yet.
- 5 want to read
- 0 reading
- 0 have read
What Wikipedia says
- published November 2009
- 392 pages
- 541 views a month
Reddit communities — coming later
Details
- First published
- 2009
- ISBN
- 9780521733663
- Editions known
- 6 at Open Library
- Open Library
- OL18486990W
Archaeology and historyArkeologiCivilizationCivilization, historyCultural developmentCulturenGefährdungGesellschaftsordnungHistoryHuman ecologyHumanekologiImperialismImperialismusPolitical aspects
Read next: its neighbours on the mosaic
CollapseJared Diamond · 2005 · recommended by 43 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The collapse of complex societiesJoseph A. Tainter · 1988 · recommended by 34 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
1177 B.C.Eric H. Cline · 2014 · recommended by 14 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Goliath's CurseLuke Kemp · 2025 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Dawn of EverythingDavid Graeber · 2021 · recommended by 110 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Darkness in El DoradoPatrick Tierney · 2000 · recommended by 0 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Beyond civilizationDaniel Quinn · 1999 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The world until yesterdayJared Diamond · 2012 · recommended by 11 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Art of Not Being GovernedJames C. Scott · 2009 · recommended by 9 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
After 1177 B. C.Eric Cline · 2024 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it
Dark Age AmericaJohn Michael Greer · 2016 · recommended by 4 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Fragments of an Anarchist AnthropologyDavid Graeber · 2004 · recommended by 6 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Seneca EffectUgo Bardi · 2017 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it
The 10,000 year explosionGregory Cochran · 2009 · recommended by 6 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Tides of HistoryPatrick Wyman · 2018 · recommended by 8 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Against the GrainJames C. Scott · 2017 · recommended by 22 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Annals of the former worldJohn McPhee · 1998 · recommended by 12 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The World Without UsAlan Weisman · 2007 · recommended by 14 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
War before civilizationLawrence H. Keeley · 1996 · recommended by 8 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
EcotopiaErnest Callenbach · 1975 · recommended by 9 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
OvershootWilliam R. Catton · 1980 · recommended by 7 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Before the dawnNicholas Wade · 2006 · recommended by 6 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
A Language Older Than WordsDerrick Jensen · 2000 · recommended by 4 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The KnowledgeLewis Dartnell · 2014 · recommended by 24 people · similar by subject and what people say about it