
Men Against Fire
S. L. A. Marshall · 1947
Politics, economics and society › War and the Holocaust
#4,854 most recommended
Hacker News
9
mentions by 8 people · top 32% of 15,732 books
Open Library
—
No ratings yet
3 want to read
Wikipedia
—
No article yet
About the book
A study of American infantry combat in the Second World War, based on after-action interviews with soldiers from units in the Pacific and European theatres. It concentrates on the small unit, the rifle company and platoon, and on what individual riflemen did and failed to do when engaged. Marshall's central claim is that in many engagements only a small minority of riflemen, by his estimate roughly one in four or fewer, fired their weapons at the enemy even when the enemy was in view. He attributes this to the psychological resistance of ordinary men to killing rather than to cowardice, and treats it as a leadership and training problem that can be corrected. He recommends cohesive small-unit leadership and training that makes firing a more automatic response, so that a larger share of the men can be brought to bear. Later historians disputed the statistical basis of these claims.
Written by Claude from what it knows of this book.
What Hacker News says 0% recommend · 38% critical
In the commenters’ own words
The book is based on research that was flat made up by S.L.A. Marshall. There is no evidence he ever collected the data he used to spread that myth. On…
It's a provocative title, but I think this section better captures his scope of argument - "Collaboration-as-ideology has made ownership and responsibility…
What Open Library readers say
No Open Library reader has rated it yet.
- 3 want to read
- 1 reading
- 0 have read
What critics say, via Wikipedia
No Wikipedia article about this book yet, so no critics to quote.
Reddit communities — coming later
Details
- First published
- 1947
- ISBN
- 9780806132808
- Editions known
- 4 at Open Library
- Open Library
- OL3843193W
Armed ForcesCommand of troopsLeadershipMoralMoraleSoldatsUnited states, armed forces
Read next: its neighbours on the mosaic
Small unit leadershipDandridge M. Malone · 1983 · recommended by 5 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
BoydRobert Coram · 2002 · recommended by 25 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Sun Tzu's art of warGeneral Tao Hanzhang · 2007 · recommended by 7 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
About faceDavid H. Hackworth · 1989 · recommended by 5 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
War is a racketSmedley D. Butler · 1935 · recommended by 50 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The mission, the men, and mePete Blaber · 2008 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Team of TeamsStanley A. McChrystal · 2015 · recommended by 17 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Command and ControlEric Schlosser · 2013 · recommended by 100 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The myth of male powerWarren Farrell · 1993 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it
On KillingDave Grossman · 1996 · recommended by 21 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Simple Sabotage Field ManualUnited States. Office of Strategic Services. · 1944 · recommended by 9 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Gates of fireSteven Pressfield · 1998 · recommended by 15 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
On WarCarl von Clausewitz · 1832 · recommended by 5 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Bomber MafiaMalcolm Gladwell · 2021 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
This kind of warT. R. Fehrenbach · 1963 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Leaders Eat LastSimon Sinek · 1900 · recommended by 15 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The human elementWilliam Schutz · 1994 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The 33 Strategies of WarRobert Greene · 2006 · recommended by 11 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
How to make warJames F. Dunnigan · 1982 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Death MarchEdward Yourdon · 2003 · recommended by 13 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Of Boys and MenRichard V. Reeves · 2022 · recommended by 0 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Corps businessDavid Freedman · 2000 · recommended by 3 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
FirepowerPaul Douglas Lockhart · 2021 · recommended by 2 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Psychological warfarePaul Myron Anthony Linebarger · 1948 · recommended by 1 person · similar by subject and what people say about it