
Lost in math
Sabine Hossenfelder · 2018
Minds, machines and the future › Cosmology and physics
#1,059 most recommended
Hacker News
46
mentions by 40 people · top 8% of 15,732 books
Open Library
3.50★★★★★★★★★★
4 ratings · 54 want to read
Wikipedia
—
No article yet
About the book
Sabine Hossenfelder, a physicist, argues that theoretical physics has gone without a major foundational breakthrough for more than forty years. She says physicists judge theories by beauty, naturalness, and elegance, and that this habit has hardened into dogma that clashes with scientific objectivity. Ideas such as supersymmetry and grand unification were built on aesthetic grounds, and observation has not confirmed them. She holds that such theories are untestable and have left the field stuck. Her remedy is for physicists to rethink their methods and accept reality as it is, whatever it looks like.
Written by Claude from the Open Library description, the Wikipedia article and the Hacker News comments.
What Hacker News says 45% recommend · 3% critical
Explains that the book targets supersymmetry because its appeal rests on aesthetic arguments, such as solving the hierarchy problem, rather than on logical necessity.
Found the book laborious and a long version of an argument made better elsewhere, and says it offers only a brief, generic path forward, though she interviewed many scholars, some of whom rejected her view.
Enjoyed the book overall but finds her mocking style unproductive, and says she does some of the same careless judging of others that she accuses physicists of.
Says she sees no nuance: with no data, work is dismissed as being lost in math, even where studying a problem like black hole information loss might be defensible.
Credits her with laying out in detail how flawed arguments for new particles get poorly motivated experiments funded that then find nothing.
The criticism. Critics find the book long-winded and short on constructive alternatives, and say its stance and snarky tone leave out nuance about work that lacks data.
What Open Library readers say 3.50 from 4 ratings
- 51
- 41
- 31
- 21
- 10
- 54 want to read
- 1 reading
- 8 have read
Only 4 ratings: treat the average as a hint.
What critics say, via Wikipedia
No Wikipedia article about this book yet, so no critics to quote.
Reddit communities — coming later
The threads it came up in
Details
- First published
- 2018
- ISBN
- 9780465094257
- Editions known
- 12 at Open Library
- Open Library
- OL19749222W
AestheticsAstronomyAstrophysicsBIOGRAPHY & AUTOBIOGRAPHYCosmologyDifferentialElectromagnetismEmpiricismEnergyEpistemologyExperiments & ProjectsGeometryGravityGroup Theory
Read next: its neighbours on the mosaic
Not Even WrongPeter Woit · 2006 · recommended by 6 people · named together in 3 comments
The Trouble With PhysicsLee Smolin · 2006 · recommended by 16 people · named together in 5 comments
Our Mathematical UniverseMax Tegmark · 2014 · recommended by 32 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
A new kind of scienceStephen Wolfram · 2002 · recommended by 44 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Love and MathEdward Frenkel · 2013 · recommended by 20 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
MathematicaDavid Bessis · 2024 · recommended by 12 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Three Roads to Quantum GravityLee Smolin · 2001 · recommended by 2 people · named together in 3 comments
Physics and philosophyWerner Heisenberg · 1958 · recommended by 6 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Elegant UniverseBrian Greene · 1999 · recommended by 20 people · named together in 3 comments
A Mathematician's LamentPaul Lockhart · 2009 · recommended by 47 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
What is real?Adam Becker · 2018 · recommended by 6 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Where Mathematics Comes FromGeorge Lakoff · 2000 · recommended by 18 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
How Not to Be WrongJordan Ellenberg · 2014 · recommended by 20 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Meta Math!Gregory Chaitin · 2005 · recommended by 11 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Something Deeply HiddenSean M. Carroll · 2019 · recommended by 12 people · named together in 2 comments
The Hidden RealityBrian Greene · 2011 · recommended by 7 people · named together in 2 comments
Proofs from the bookMartin Aigner · 1998 · recommended by 28 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
Weapons of Math DestructionCathy O'Neil · 2016 · recommended by 68 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
MeasurementPaul Lockhart · 2012 · recommended by 23 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Mathematical ExperiencePhilip J. Davis · 1980 · recommended by 20 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Character of Physical LawRichard Phillips Feynman · 1965 · recommended by 14 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The fractal geometry of natureBenoît B. Mandelbrot · 1982 · recommended by 8 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Road to RealityRoger Penrose · 2004 · recommended by 67 people · similar by subject and what people say about it
The Signal and the NoiseNate Silver · 2012 · recommended by 47 people · 2 people recommended both